New Analysis Discredits Data Found in NGO “Unsafe” Toy Reports

NEW YORK – The Toy Industry Association (TIA) is warning consumers to be wary of misleading reports circulated by non-governmental organizations (NGOs) regarding allegedly harmful toys.

The TIA conducted a thorough analysis of U.S. Public Interest Research Group’s (PIRG) 2015 “Trouble in Toyland” report and W.A.T.C.H’s 2015 “10 Worst Toys” list. The analysis revealed that the data provided by these groups is unreliable and consistently fails to support their allegations that the listed toys present any danger to children at play.

“The toy community remains steadfast in its year-round commitment to creating safe toys and games that bring joy and learning to children all over the world. However, each holiday season, a small group of non-governmental organizations seeks to generate publicity and donations for themselves with their alleged ‘unsafe’ toy reports,” said Steve Pasierb, TIA president and CEO. “These reports are not backed up with credible, scientific data, and instead needlessly frighten families during an otherwise joyful time of year. In fact, all toys sold in the U.S. are highly regulated 365 days a year by the federal government and must meet more than 100 safety requirements.”

The TIA released the following information in its report:

- None of the toys that PIRG and W.A.T.C.H. named in their reports have been recalled by the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC), the federal agency charged with overseeing toy safety, as a result of their allegations.

- W.A.T.C.H. does not test any of the toys it claims are unsafe. Their allegations are based on pure conjecture and opinion.

- PIRG also failed to use proper toy testing methods. Only one out of the 23 products named in PIRG’s report was properly tested by the group for safety.

- Toy safety and protecting children at play is the top priority of the toy industry. TIA welcomes independent monitoring and analysis by outside parties – as long as these activities are carried out in a responsible manner. Unfortunately, groups like PIRG and W.A.T.C.H. do nothing to advance toy safety and are not serving the interests and well-being of children and their families.

- TIA was a vigorous supporter of the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act, the federal consumer product safety legislation adopted in 2008, and works year-round with medical experts, consumer groups and government regulators to ensure the safety of children and maintain U.S. toy safety standards, which are among the strictest in the world. The Association educates toymakers on how to meet these standards and provides consumers with accurate facts about toy safety.

The TIA’s features toy safety facts, recall information and tips for safe play.

Playthings Staff | Playthings Staff

We cover the latest news and information for the toy industry.

Research Store

Buyers Guide Search
Search for Products/Companies

Featured Video

Subscribe to
Gifts & Dec Direct
Receive the news you need to know about the trends in the industry delivered right to your inbox.

AmericasMart ICON Honorees

ICON videos of honorees

Excellence and superior achievement in the home and gift industry were recognized in July at AmericasMart's eighth annual ICON Honors. Enjoy these video stories celebrating the 2017 award recipients: Spicher and Company, Bloomingville, Wolf Gourmet, Her Majesty's English Tea Room, Kurt S. Adler, Inc., and Chris Rosse, Rosse and Associates. See the videos!


GDA Cover September 2017

See the September 2017 issue of Gifts & Dec.  We look at how Millennials are changing the tabletop industry, plus what retailers can do to reduce theft. Get details!